Main
Menu
|
|
|
Submissions |
|
Submit
a Review
If
you're involved in a horror movie, book or game and would like
to see it reviewed on HorrorWatch, click
here.
|
|
|
Battle
Royale
|
|
Could
you kill your best friend?
|
|
|
|
|
When
Paynecraft generously gave me permission to review this (it was
originally going to be written by him) I nearly wet myself. It’s
safe to say I’m a fanboy, not necessarily of Battle Royale
so much as of “Beat” Takeshi Kitano, who plays the teacher in
the film. Takeshi easily rivals the intensity of such American
actors as Eastwood and DeNiro, and he does not disappoint here.
In the alternate reality of Battle Royale (the film is
set in 2000, the year it was released theatrically), Japan is
fighting back against its rebellious youth. Tired of a society
in which a mounting lack of respect is shown, the government passes
a law that, once a year, places the worst class of a randomly
drawn high school on an island. The purpose? A game to the death:
Each person is given a random weapon and, at the end of three
days, only one person can be left alive.
The most disturbing thing here is that these kids are not demons;
they’re typical emotional teenagers with real-world concerns and
reactions. In the midst of all the carnage, which some people
have trouble accepting as real, friends have crushes and playfully
bicker, all the while knowing that the deadline (and that word
is very appropriate) is fast approaching. How would you
respond? Given no choice, could you kill your best friend?
Battle Royale is not horror in the classic sense; rather
it is a suspense film that is, at times, quite horrifying because
we can see how close to reality the behaviors exhibited by these
characters actually are. Rather than flesh out whole characters,
the film is content to parade a host of different personalities
before us, most of whom you will recognize in the people around
you, and that’s the scariest thing of all: you know people
who would act like this. In fact, in all probability, you
will recognize yourself onscreen.
The emotional impact of this film packs a wallop. There’s more,
though. There’s an undertone of disgust to the entire piece, not
aimed at the children, but at government. Additionally, it has
some haunting visuals. The image of a previous winner of the game
- smiling, holding her rag doll, and covered in blood - rates
right up there with any of Kubrik’s signature shots (D’Onofrio
in Full Metal Jacket or Nicholson in The
Shining, for example). You won’t easily forget her.
Unfortunately, Battle Royale is not yet available in America
(or Great Britain, I believe) except on an import disc. I picked
up an exellent VCD set (legit, by the way) on eBay for $9 a couple
of years ago, so you can get it on the cheap; it is worth
the trouble.
Incidentally, fans of Quentin Tarentino’s Kill Bill, Volume
One will recognize Chiaki Kuriyama, who played the assassin
Gogo, complete with the same schoolgirl uniform she wears in Battle
Royale. It’s safe to say Mr. Tarentino is a fanboy, too.
Pros:
Has the balls to show an amazingly disturbing concept. Also has
characters reacting realistically …
Cons:
…in a fairly unrealistic setting. Additionally, the ending may
throw some viewers.
Review
Rating: 9 out of 10 stars.
|
|
Battle
Royale
|
|
Could
you kill your best friend?
|
|
|
|
|
Now
this was a great fucking movie! The concept isn't completely
original, but it was carried out to near perfection. A very brutal
film, made even more brutal by the fact that these were boys and
girls hacking and stabbing at each other. At one point a girl
with a knife was fighting a boy with a crossbow or something (I
forget exactly). The girl gets the upper hand, jumps on top of
him and starts stabbing him in the balls. That's good stuff!
I enjoyed the real aspects of the movie also. From an emotional
standpoint that is. Even not knowing the Japanese culture extensively,
I appreciated the fact that some kids would rather kill themselves
than be forced to kill their friends. It sounds bold, but I would
wager realistic, especially at a younger age when such notions
are underdeveloped and not thoroughly rationalized out.
There is a definite sense of despair in the movie. There is seemingly
no way out of the situation, except kill everybody. Not good.
If you can find this movie go get it. I give it 9.5 out of 10
machine gun blood bath inducing spaghetti dinners. Anybody for
seconds?
Incidentally I would give this movie 10 out of 10 if I can figure
out what the hell was up with the ending. Once I find out, I reserve
the right to move it up to a 10 if I am satisfied with what I
read.
|
|
Battle
Royale
|
|
Could
you kill your best friend?
|
|
|
|
|
Our
previous two pros nailed this review right on the bloody head!!!
An outstanding story carried out with damn near perfect execution.
Allow me if you will to get my two gripes out of the way. The
single psychopath who volunteered for the Battle Royale
was enjoying it just a little too much, and had a seemingly ENDLESS
supply of ammo for his Uzi (which is known to eat ammo like crazy)
can we say Rambo clip? While other poor kids who got firearms
had a pretty limited supply (in most cases)
Second, I'm gonna have to side with Payne and say "What
the hell was up with that ending?" It was fine, but Takeshi's
little indecisiveness as to whether or not he was dead, was strange,
maybe a little too much so.
Last, the Japanese to English translation was pretty bad at some
points. Example:
Girl: You look really cool.
Guy: You’re the coolest girl in the world.
This is the exchange between the two as she's dying. How's
that for cheese?
The "contest" was well thought out by the writers, they
had great ideas to satisfy just about every "what if"
you could think of. Shifting danger zones, "Deadlock"
style collars that can detonate at a moments notice.... Lots of
thought went into it.
The gore was copious and pretty well done, once it started, it
never really stopped.
And Payne, having lived in Japan for 4 years I will state that
yes, the suicidal teens are definitely a commentary on the culture,
as a matter of fact the suicide rate is high amongst teens in
Japan, especially when obesity, STD's, or unplanned teen
pregnancy is involved, and almost every single instance I heard
about when I was there, involved jumping off of buildings or bridges
(often in groups as a suicide pact). Hope that clarifies the issue
for you.
A great film, sent to me by the oh-so-gracious Taconator. Thanks
again bro, mucho gusto!!!
If anyone sees this and wonders why the "teacher" looks
familiar, that's because he's the host on Spike TV's
"MXC" known in Japan as Takeshi's Castle. He's
also been in countless Japanese horror/thriller/action movies,
and has been in a few American flicks like Johnny Mnemonic (okay
bad example)
9 out of 10 Decapitated heads with live grenades clenched in their
teeth.
|
|
Search
the Site |
|
|
|